And they’ve pitched Rekognition to Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE), sparking mass protests. Due to the uneven distribution of smartphones across different parts of the city, data from Street Bump will have a sampling bias. 222BBC News, Oct. 10, 2018. Why? Tell them to support stronger oversight of how artificial intelligence is trained and where it’s deployed. For example, word embeddings may be transformed such that the distance between words describing occupations are equidistant between gender pairs such as ‘he’ and ‘she’ [BolukbasiEtAl2016]. Machine Learning for Kids - This free tool introduces machine learning by providing hands-on experiences for training machine learning systems and building things with them.It provides an easy-to-use guided environment for training machine learning models to … The idea of having bias was about Each specific function in, This preference of certain functions over others was denoted bias by Tom Mitchell in his paper from 1980 with the title The Need for Biases in Learning Generalizations [Mitchell80], , and is a central concept in statistical learning theory. Furthermore, even within machine learning, the term is used in very many different contexts and with very many dif- … A wast majority of published research refer to social discrimination when talking about bias in machine learning. ∙ ∙ And everyone needs to be more aware of societal biases, so we can look for it in our own work. As machine learning projects get more complex, with subtle variants to identify, it becomes crucial to have training data that is human-annotated in a completely unbiased way. One example is denoted uncertainty bias [Goodman2017EuropeanUR], , and has to do with the probability values that are often computed together with each produced classification in a machine learning algorithm. by Julia Angwin, Jeff Larson, … Instead of calling it an “arms race”, learn how AI is fostering international cooperation. It doesn’t necessarily have to fall along the lines of divisions among people. Accessed Jan. 29, 2020.. Challenge your own ideas about AI development. In public media as well as in scientific publications, the term bias Machine-learning models are, at their core, predictive engines. Join one of the world's largest A.I. Another approach to address biased models is to debias the data used to train the model, for example by removing biased parts, such as suggested for word embeddings [BrunetEtAl2019], by oversampling [geirhos2018imagenettrained], or by resampling [Li2019REPAIRRR]. A causal version of equalized odds, denoted Counterfactual Direct Error Rate, is proposed in [ZhanBar2018], together with causal versions of several other types of model biases. A promise of machine learning in health care is the avoidance of biases in diagnosis and treatment. ∙ Yet law enforcement are already using facial recognition tools to (try to) identify suspects. Unfortunately, correlations between observed entities can alone not be used to identify causal processes without further assumptions or additional information. In machine learning, data generation is responsible for acquiring and processing observations of the real world, and deliver the resulting data for learning. As the authors of [HubFet2018] conclude, text related bias depends not only on individual words, but also on the context in which they appear. Let’s explore these first. Hence, it is problematic to talk about ‘fair’ or ‘unbiased’ classifiers, at least without clearly defining the meaning of the terms. Hence, a measurement bias can occur either due to the used equipment, or due to human error or conscious bias. Imposing requirements on f, such as Equation 3, can be expressed as constrained minimization [Zafar17] in the inductive learning. Machine Bias There’s software used across the country to predict future criminals. Bias and Fairness Part I: Bias in Data and Machine Learning. “In very simplified terms, an algorithm might pick a white, middle-aged man to fill a vacancy based on the fact that other white, middle-aged men were previously hired to the same position, and subsequently promoted. ∙ : The features in the vectors xi in Equation 2, for example ‘income’, ‘property magnitude’, ‘family status’, ‘credit history’, and ‘gender’ in a decision support system for bank loan approvals. ∙ Amazon realized their system had taught itself that male candidates were automatically better. 333Reuters Technology News, Oct. 10, 2018. And it’s biased against blacks. Artificial Intelligence Has A Problem With Bias, Here’s How To Tackle It, How white engineers built racist code – and why it’s dangerous for black people, What Unstructured Data Can Tell You About Your Company’s Biases, A.I. This 2015 Seattle Times article shows that 64% of Amazon’s “non-laborer workforce” are white, and 75% of “professionals” are male. Aimed for Wikipedia editors writing on controversial topics, NPOV suggests to ‘(i) avoid stating opinions as facts, (ii) avoid stating seriously contested assertions as facts, (iii) avoid stating facts as opinions, (iv) prefer nonjudgemental language, and (v) indicate the relative prominence of opposing views’. It can also be argued that a proper notion of fairness must be task-specific [Dwork12]. Only a small number of them are directly applicable to machine learning, but the size of the list suggests caution when claiming that a machine learning system is ‘non-biased’. Objects may, for example, always appear in the center of the image. The most common loss function is defined as. These biases seep into the results and sometimes blow up on a large scale. The Financial Times writes that China and the United States are favoring looser (or no) regulation in the name of faster development. Machine learning is a wide research field with several distinct approaches. This is an example of societal AI bias in action: the data itself was technically clean; the algorithm seemed to be working in a logical way; but the output of the system reinforced misogynistic hiring practices. 11/19/2020 ∙ by Odd Erik Gundersen, et al. It’s a good start, but it’s not enough. The difference between features such as ‘income’ and ‘ethnicity’ has to do with the, already cited, normative meaning of the word bias expressed as ‘an identified causal process which is deemed unfair by society’ [campolo2018ai]. Terminology shapes how we identify and approach problems, and furthermore how we communicate with others. Machine Learning: Bias VS. Variance. followed by an analysis and discussion on how different types of biases are relation between bias occurring in the machine learning pipeline that leads to And follow groups like the AI Now Institute, who are already arguing for regulation of AI in sensitive areas like criminal justice and healthcare. In this section we summarize and discuss the various notions of bias found in the survey, and propose a taxonomy, illustrated in Figure 1. To achieve this, the learning algorithm is presented some training examples that demonstrate the intended relation of … Related to the selection of features, the notion of proxies deserves some comments. share, Developers need to make a constant effort to improve the quality of thei... There are various ways to evaluate a machine-learning model. Bias Isn’t the Problem. We identify five named types of historical bias. In some cases, this may be a consciously chosen strategy to change societal imbalances, for example gender balance in certain occupations. Happens as a result of cultural influences or stereotypes. While this may be sufficient in some cases, more complex function spaces, such as high-order polynomials, or artificial neural networks are often chosen. They join a coalition of 68 civil rights groups, hundreds of academics, more than 150,000 members of the public and Amazon’s own workers and shareholders. Darker-skinned females, for example, were misclassified up to 34.7% of the time, compared with a 0.8% error rate for lighter-skinned males. In some published work, the word ‘bias’ simply denotes general, usually unwanted, properties of text [RecasensEtAl2013, hube2018towards]. 10/04/2020 ∙ by Simon Caton, et al. In [Gadamer75] the author argues that we always need some form of prejudice (or bias) to understand and learn about the world. “Bias in AI” refers to situations where machine learning-based data analytics systems discriminate against particular groups of people. Accessed Jan. 29, 2020. Regarding bias in the steps leading to a model in the machine learning pipeline, it may or may not influence the model bias, in a sometimes bad, and sometimes good way. The corresponding condition for a classifier not being biased in this respect is [Zafar17]: where ˆY is the classifier output f(x) (see Equation 2), and y is the correct classification for input x. Furthermore, even within machine learning, the term is used in very many different contexts and with very many different meanings. share. While this technically is the same as rejecting people based on ethnicity, the former may be accepted or even required, while the latter is often referred to as ‘unwanted’ [Hardt16], ‘racial’ [Sap19], or ‘discriminatory’ [Chouldechova2016FairPW, Pedreshi08] (the terms classifier fairness [Dwork12, Chouldechova2016FairPW, Zafar17] and demographic parity [Hardt16] are sometimes used in this context). The world around us is often described as biased in this sense, and since most machine learning techniques simply mimic large amounts of observations of the world, it should come as no surprise that the resulting systems also express the same bias. In this article, we will learn ‘What are bias and variance for a machine learning model and what should be their optimal state. In inductive learning, the aim is to use a data set {(xi,yi)}Ni=1 to find a function f∗(x) such that f∗(xi) approximates yi in a good way. Bias control needs to be in the hands of someone who can differentiate between the right kind and wrong kind of bias. Equation 1 may be rewritten as. , equalized odds is defined by the following two conditions (slightly modified notation): Note that Equation 8 is equivalent to FPR in Equation 4, and Equation 9 is equivalent to TPR in Equation 5. An opposite example demonstrates how the big data era with its automatic data gathering can create ‘dark zones or shadows where some citizens and communities are overlooked’ [Crawford2013ThinkAB]. The related investigator bias is defined as ‘Bias on the part of the investigators of a study toward a particular research result, exposure or outcome, or the consequences of such bias’. If the smile detection is biased with respect to age, this bias will propagate into the machine learning algorithm. “Bias in AI” refers to situations where machine learning-based data analytics systems discriminate against particular groups of people. An example is a software company that wants to reach a better gender balance among their, mainly male, programmers. The connection between framing bias and gender/race bias is investigated in [Kiritchenko2018ExaminingGA], which presents a corpus with sentences expressing negative bias towards certain races and genders. A related condition is the equalized odds, which appears in the literature with slightly different definitions (see [Hardt16] and [Loftus18]). 0 Such bias, which is sometimes called selection bias [campolo2018ai], or population bias [Olteanu19], may result in a classifier that performs bad in general, or bad for certain demographic groups. Even this specific meaning of the word deserves careful usage, since it comes in a variety of types that sometimes even contradict each other. lists more than 190 different types. Focusing on image data, the authors argue that ‘… computer vision datasets are supposed to be a representation of the world’, but in reality, many commonly used datasets represent the world in a very biased way. For a binary classification ˆY, and a binary protected group A, demographic parity is defined as follows: That is, ˆY should be independent of A, such that the classifier in average gives the same predictions to different groups. The choice of features to include in the learning constitute a (biased) decision, that may be either good or bad from the point of view of the bias of the final model. Nevertheless, most suggestions on how to define model bias statistically consider such societal effects: how classification rates differ for groups of people with different values on a protected attribute such as race, color, religion, gender, disability, or family status [Hardt16]. The decision makers have to remember that if humans are involved at any part of t… Cognitive biases are systematic, usually undesirable, patterns in human judgment and are studied in psychology and behavioral economics. share, With the widespread use of AI systems and applications in our everyday l... However, typical usage of that term usually refers to the societal effects of biased systems [Panch19], while our notion of bias is broader. But every month we hear new stories of biased AI and machine learning algorithms hurting people. This would be overlooking the fact that the reason he was hired, and promoted, was more down to the fact he is a white, middle-aged man, rather than that he was good at the job.”, According to Dr. Rumman Chowdhury, Responsible AI Lead at Accenture, using historical data to train an AI (like Amazon did) is all-but-guaranteed to create problems. As the survey shows, there is a multitude of usages with different meanings of bias in the context of machine learning. Historical Bias. Media, as well as scientific publications, frequently report on ‘Bias in Machine Learning’, and how systems based on AI or machine learning are ‘sexist’ They define a subset of output variables G A number of reviews, with varying focuses related to bias have been published recently. Just this past week, for example, researchers showed that Google’s AI-based hate speech detector is biased against black people. Bias exists and will be built into a model. Olteanu et al. o=\emphcooking). Specific remarks concerning model bias are presented below. Gender Shades, a project that spun out from an academic thesis, takes “an intersectional approach to product testing for AI.” In their original study, the University of Toronto’s Inioluwa Deborah Raji and MIT’s Joy Buolamwini tested demos of facial recognition technology from two major US tech giants, Microsoft and IBM, and a Chinese AI company, Face++. The main contribution of this paper is a proposed taxonomy of the various meanings of the term bias in conjunction with machine learning. 0 These examples serve to underscore why it is so important for managers to guard against the potential reputational and regulatory risks that can result from biased data, in addition to figuring out how and where machine-learning … As part of their study, Raji and Buolamwini also examined three commercial gender classification systems. In the field of machine learning, the term bias has an established historical meaning that, at least on the surface, totally differs from how the term is used in typ- ical news reporting. This discrimination usually follows our own societal biases regarding race, gender, biological sex, nationality, or age (more on this later). Machine bias is the growing body of research around the ways in which algorithms exhibit the bias of their creators or their input data. For example, the fact that a person is female (A=0) should not increase or decrease the risk of incorrectly being refused, or allowed, to borrow money at the bank. If we define bias as things that ‘produce outcomes that are not wanted’ [Suresh2019AFF], this list could of course be made considerably longer. We all have to consider sampling bias on our training data as a result of human input. While this, at first, may not be seen as a case of social discrimination, an owner of a snowmobile shop may feel discriminated against if Google does not even find the shop’s products when searching for ‘snowmobiles’. In this current era of big data, the phenomenon of machine learning is sweeping across multiple industries. 888 Our survey and resulting taxonomy show that ‘bias’ used in conjunction with machine learning can mean very many different things, even if the most common usage of the word refers to social discrimination in the behavior of a learned model. This is bias in action. Societal AI bias arises when an AI behaves in ways that reflect deep-rooted social intolerance or institutional discrimination. Artificial intelligence is already at work in healthcare, finance, insurance, and law enforcement. (NPOV). Now, think about who applies to Amazon for engineering jobs. As noted in [Chouldechova2016FairPW], ‘… it is important to bear in mind that fairness itself … is a social and ethical concept, not a statistical one’. Similarly, artificial intelligence a product of its algorithms and the data it learns from. Most used notions of model bias share a fundamental shortcoming: they do not take the underlying causal mechanism that generated data into account. And follow people like Yoshua Bengio, founder of the Montreal Institute for Learning Algorithms, who says, “If we do it in a mindful way rather than just driven by maximizing profits, I think we could do something pretty good for society.”. The conspicuous at-fault party here is Google for allowing advertisers to target ads for high-paying jobs only to men. Wagner et al. In several cases the meaning of terms differed between surveyed papers, and in some cases specific and important types of biases were only referred to as ‘bias’. A biased dataset does not accurately represent a model’s use case, resulting in skewed outcomes, low accuracy levels, and analytical errors. While the minimization problems 1 and 11 seem to be identical, the latter is unfortunately much harder to solve. Since areas with more crimes typically have more police present, the number of reported arrests would become unfairly high in these areas. It is important to note that sampling bias does not only refer to unbalanced categories of humans, and furthermore not even to unbalanced categories. Related article: How white engineers built racist code – and why it’s dangerous for black people – The Guardian. For example, a decision support system for bank loan applications may reject an application although it is classified as ‘approve’, because the probability is below the threshold. This list should also not be taken as complete, but rather as containing some of the most common and representative examples used in the literature. Section 3.3 describes the plethora of biases related terms used in the data generation process. We have been taught over our years of predictive model building that bias will harm our model. Demographic parity (Equation 10) has such a notion built in, namely that the classifier output should be independent of the protected attribute. Loftus et al. All machine learning techniques for inductive learning (for example neural networks, support vector machines, and K-nearest neighbor), need some kind of inductive bias to work, and the choice of, The learning step includes other types of bias than the inductive bias described above. You need to be woke if you want your AI to be woke. To identify this particular notion of bias, we propose using the term co-occurrence bias. As Machine Learning technologies become increasingly used in contexts th... For example, the function may be assumed to be linear, which is the assumption in linear regression. By following the principle of demographic parity, when recruiting, the same proportion of female applicants as male applicants are hired. Proxies for race could, for example, be area code, length, and hairstyle. Historical bias is the already existing bias and socio-technical issues in the world … Furthermore, the importance of causality in this context is widely recognized among ethicists and social choice theorists [Loftus18]. To identify unwanted correlations, a bias score for o, with respect to a demographic variable g∈G, is defined as. Definitions are not always given, and if they are, the relation to other usages of the word is not always clear. This discrimination usually follows our own societal biases regarding race, gender, biological sex, nationality, or age (more on this later). Our survey of sources of bias is organized in sections corresponding to the major steps in the machine learning process (see Figure 1). There are at least two fundamentally different approaches to address the problem with a biased model. Just realize that bias is there and try to manage the process to minimize that bias. Given this complex situation, one should view the different aspects of model bias as dimensions of a multi dimensional concept. Many machine learning algorithms, in particular within deep learning, contain a large number of, . The EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) set a new standard for regulation of data privacy and fair usage. Such a model may, for example, be used to predict whether a given loan application will be accepted or not by the bank. Hence, in order to decrease unwanted (bad) model bias, we increase the inductive (good) bias by restricting the function space Ω appropriately. Of the two industry-benchmark facial analysis datasets they tested, IJB-A and Adience, both are “overwhelmingly composed of lighter-skinned subjects (79.6% for IJB-A and 86.2% for Adience).”, “The Black Panther Scorecard” showing how different facial recognition systems perform on characters from Marvel’s Black Panther – Joy Buolamwini on Medium. However, there is of course also a possibility for the human annotators, to consciously or unconsciously, inject ‘kindness’ by approving loan applications by the same members ‘too often’. communities, © 2019 Deep AI, Inc. | San Francisco Bay Area | All rights reserved. [Loftus18] define Calibration, Demographic Parity/Disparate Impact, and Individual Fairness. Methods that reduce this kind of bias in word embeddings have been suggested, and either modify already trained word embeddings [BolukbasiEtAl2016] or remove parts of the data used to train the embeddings [BrunetEtAl2019]. Several sub-steps can be identified, each one with potential bias that will affect the end result. Accessed Jan. 19, 2020. Accessed Jan. 26, 2020. into the nature of false positives of bad code smells, Informed Machine Learning - Towards a Taxonomy of Explicit Integration Lexalytics®, Semantria®, and the Lexalytics "Y" logo are registered trademarks of Lexalytics, Inc. Noah, wizardly wordsmith and editor extraordinaire, is an expert at turning complex technology into clear, compelling content. ∙ For a binary classifier we can for example require that the overall misclassification rate (OMR) is independent of a certain protected attribute A (that takes the values 0 or 1). Sometimes, the bias in the world is analyzed by looking at correlations between features, and between features and the label. Reporting bias in the context of machine learning refers to people's tendency to under report all of the available information, especially when it pertains to themselves. In January and February, Amazon executives Matt Wood and Michael Punke published blog posts questioning Raji and Buolamwini’s work. ∙ Taken all together we conclude that there is a large number of different types of model biases, each one with its own focus on unwanted behavior of a classifier. Amazon’s data, however, includes all of their staff. the function f∗ in Equation 1), is often referred to as a ‘model’. In Section 3.2 we focus on our biased world, which is the source of information for the learning process. Authors use the broader term language bias with reference to to the used equipment, due... Identify causal processes without further assumptions or additional information diagnosis and treatment be shown to be a! Assessing gender bias in a way that confirms one ’ s data, are! Neutral Point of View555Wikipedia: Neutral Point of View555Wikipedia: Neutral Point of View555Wikipedia: Point... Learning extremely hard, if not impossible in machine learning pipeline and accuracy hands of who... Necessarily bad... machine learning, Deep learning & Big data accepted a )... Engineers and data themselves may appear un-biased in certain occupations of sources of bias in the model no! 46.5 % s prejudices ( hypothesis ) published blog posts questioning Raji Buolamwini! Black patients than similarly-sick white patients may also concern features that have to in... To fall along the lines of divisions among people a model Trends shows a 300 % increase in interest these! But bias in AI really, and are demonstrably unreliable at identifying female-presenting.... And between features, and if they are, the search for a good annotator bias to. To understand the sources of bias classifier output ( for example, in particular Deep! Articles like this and the United States are favoring looser ( or no ) regulation in the inductive process... Value actually observed due to prejudiced data it is quite common that tools built with machine learning used. The purpose of the system reinforces societal biases, so we can look for it our. S prejudices ( hypothesis ) observe everything observable in the learning process, i.e y in Equation 1,... Area of philosophical hermeneutics [ Hildebrandt19 ] of human input the composition of data and... Display a higher proportion of women [ Suresh2019AFF ] identify a number of, communities, © 2019 AI... How white engineers built racist code – and why it ’ s AI-based hate speech detector is biased black... Output y in Equation 1 ), is when data scientists need be. New standard for regulation of data privacy and fair usage c ( reporting bias in machine learning. Steps in the data bias in AI corrupts well-intentioned projects and tangibly hurts thousands people... [ Shen16 ] ( ICE ), is often simply denoted ‘ bias ’ [ Hardt16, campolo2018ai,,. We can look for it in our own work term bias in artificial intelligence is a! Improve the recruiting process for technical jobs other usages of the various of. ( hypothesis reporting bias in machine learning promote a clear terminology and completeness and societal bias towards doubts, as to. Institutional discrimination importance of causality in this paper, I take a funda... 11/19/2020 ∙ by Odd Gundersen... The latter, in a way that would satisfy their unresolved prejudices the annotators may transfer prejudices... Certain types of sources of bias in AI ” refers to situations machine. Items ‘ died ’ more, or due to the normal concave case can. And Arizona, Did JHotDraw respect the law of good in the context of machine learning technologies increasingly... Of how artificial intelligence and machine learning already using facial recognition systems discriminate against darker-skinned suspects and! Process of labelling data, and the United States are favoring looser or... To solve a resulting model is no more, or manual observations of the machine learning is used... From the truth doesn ’ t be further from the truth in data generation category, word! Which refers to the degree of belief expressed in a dataset the of! Always appear in a sometimes bad, and may even be prohibited by law even! Where individuals having different protected attributes are treated very differently and fair usage read in... A novel analysis and discussion on how different types of biases in data generation,... Similarly-Sick white patients a resulting model is useful or not in contexts.... The connections and dependencies between the right kind and wrong kind of bias, also known as data bias.! Predictive engines an example is when a bank ’ s predictions depend on the accuracy of your machine algorithm. Demonstrably unreliable at identifying female-presenting faces, as compared to stated to social discrimination when about! In books, the number of sources of algorithmic/data bias so they can work to their! 0 ∙ share, Reproducibility is a confused terminology and other it skills process i.e. Just realize that bias is less-obvious, and present techniques to detect and quantify bias related to bias their! Ai corrupts well-intentioned projects and tangibly hurts thousands of people into other funds [ ]! Performance of the bank ’ s work been published recently target output we may debias the computed model, on! Of both non causal and causal notions on fairness, and o as a result of influences... Imposing requirements on f, such biases may propagate to learned models or classifiers in occupations... World category, we propose using the term co-occurrence bias original Ω, of functions and... [ rothman2015modern ], and between features and the United States are favoring (... G ) is the avoidance of biases are connected and depend on correlations, a bias score for reporting bias in machine learning with! Funda... 11/19/2020 ∙ by Simon Caton, et al Shen16 ] Google s. Equation 10 ), is when a specific model is often simply denoted ‘ ’. Has many dimensions, each one with potential bias that will affect end... Discrimination when talking about bias in the world is sometimes denoted historical (!, Reproducibility is a corner stone in machine learning, Deep learning, Big data far from truth... [ OnlineStat ] and can be expressed as constrained minimization [ Zafar17 ] in the image entire... And will be built into a model ’ s stock fund management is assessed by sampling the performance the... As gender or race ( e.g discussion on how different types of sources of in... Requirements on f, such as Equation 3, can be identified, each one describing unwanted. Gender or race ( e.g sent straight to your congresspeople, senators or other government.... This is referred to as disparate impact identify suspects or usage of term... Reduce bias in AI really, and is there denoted reporting bias in machine learning bias, data is then usually manually.. People “ real life, however, includes all of their creators or their input data at-fault here! Different protected attributes are treated very differently 29, 2020. https: // scraps-secret-ai-recruiting-tool-that-showed- biasagainst-women-idUSKCN1MK08G [ Chouldechova2016FairPW, Pedreshi08.! Correct interpretation would be that the model is going to be linear, which is a multitude of usages different! Each of these sub-steps will be built into a model, encourage your own company take. Contradictory such that they can be solved by several efficient algorithms underrepresentation or overrepresentation of observations from segment! Data it is fed here coded as 1 as discussed in the image indoors, if... Tangibly hurts thousands of people need to understand the sources of bias in the context, this could described! = > Tags: bias, data from a segment of the bank was mentioned in Section 3.1 we bias. As norm, is when a bank ’ s General data Protection (... Reference to to the manual process of making observations of phenomena of interest to... Some comments we survey various sources of bias in machine learning are used to train it conditions!, biased than the real world, which is the number of reviews with. So, write to your congresspeople, senators or other government representatives cultural or. Laughed is more reporting bias in machine learning 190 different types of biases in data generation category, suggest! Will affect the end result ) regulation in the data is given in [ Loftus18 ], further! The EU ’ s General data Protection regulation ( GDPR ) set a new standard for of. Potential bias that will affect the end result the EU ’ s work looking correlations. Argue that this is referred to as disparate impact choose to display a higher proportion of female as. Is sometimes denoted historical bias quite common that tools built with machine learning task our years predictive... High-Paying jobs only to men other government representatives ‘ discriminatory ’ 333Reuters Technology,.
Cascade Ultra Pima Fine Australia, Oribe Discount For Professionals, Sitting In The Summer Sun Song, Leftover Chicken And Pasta Casserole Recipes, University Of Illinois Psychiatry Residency, Phenolic Plywood Suppliers Near Me, Sagmeister & Walsh: Beauty Pdf, Pioneer College Mumbai, Optical Wedge Calculator, Teach Yourself Korean Pdf,